When we think about ourselves, we often feel like two different things at once: a physical body that occupies space and follows the laws of physics, and a "mind" or "soul" that experiences thoughts, feelings, and consciousness. This intuitive feeling is the foundation of one of the most enduring debates in the philosophy of mind: Dualism. Specifically, Substance Dualism seeks to explain whether the mind is a distinct entity from the body or merely a function of the brain.
What is Substance Dualism?
At the heart of this topic is the concept of a "substance." In philosophy, a substance is something that can exist independently; it does not need to be "in" something else to exist. Substance Dualism is the view that the universe contains two fundamentally different kinds of substances: physical matter and mental substance.
- Physical Substance (Res Extensa): This refers to matter. Physical things have extension, meaning they take up space, have shape, and can be measured by dimensions like height, width, and depth.
- Mental Substance (Res Cogitans): This refers to the mind. Unlike matter, the mind does not have a physical shape or location in space. You cannot measure the "width" of a thought or the "weight" of a memory.
Cartesian Dualism: The Mind-Body Split
The most famous proponent of this view was René Descartes. Cartesian Dualism posits that the mind and the body are not just different properties of the same thing, but two entirely separate "stuffs".
Descartes arrived at this through a process of radical doubt. He realized he could doubt the existence of his body (it could be an illusion or a dream), but he could not doubt the existence of his mind, because the very act of doubting required a thinker. This led to his famous dictum, Cogito, ergo sum ("I think, therefore I am"). Because the mind is known with certainty while the body is not, Descartes concluded they must be distinct entities.
Keep reading for free.
Create an account to finish this reading and make it part of your study routine.
Continue reading freeAlready have an account? Log in
Updated